ree: photo of a woman with long blonde hair and glasses (Dream blue gradient)
Ree 💚 ([personal profile] ree) wrote2009-05-07 06:29 pm

custom layers and styles

I'm disappointed that Dreamwidth has allowed free users to create a custom style.

The thing about creativity is that restrictions cause it to flourish in a different way. DiaryLand has infamously hideous default templates; that very fugliness has caused countless users to design their own layouts and offer them to others.

I had hoped that Dreamwidth's relatively few system styles would cause designers to take up those styles, particularly the widely-used-at-Dreamwidth Transmogrified, and create stylish CSS to lay atop them. Instead, I'm seeing a small proliferation of LJ-to-DW layout ports: it started with Mixit, but now I'm seeing Opal too.

I'm the pot calling the kettle black - at the moment, I have Bloggish with non-LJ CSS - but don't you see? I don't want Bloggish. I want Transmogrified, or another Dreamwidth exclusive, something that harnesses Dreamwidth's style system changes and makes them something awesome, and I want it to be pretty.

Maybe some clever designer-hacker will make a versatile S2 style out of scratch, but I expect the vast majority of layouts offered on Dreamwidth layout communities to be ports and knockoffs from LJ. And that's sad, because Dreamwidth deserves better than that.